► Vivek Ramaswamy: Today’s “Defaming Loser” Award Winner Print E-mail

Vivek Ramaswamy: Today’s “Defaming Loser” Award Winner

 

Vivek Ramaswamy appears to have discovered early in life that making an honest living practicing law might require more work than he cared to put in. So, naturally, he went looking for another line of work where ambition, self-promotion, and a flexible relationship with good taste might prove more lucrative.

 

But that raises an important question: What is the second-most honest and ethical profession in America?

 

“What’s number one, Dave?”

 

“Come on, Delmas. Everybody knows it’s used-car salesmen.”

 

“Fine. If used-car salesmen rank number one and lawyers come in at number two, what profession claims the bronze medal?”

 

“Ministers, Delmas.”

 

“So, you’re telling me that, when it comes to integrity and virtue, a man of the cloth ranks below a used-car salesman and an attorney?”

 

“That’s right, Delmas. You’re finally catching on.”

 

Of course, this is satire. I wouldn’t want to insult honest used-car salespeople, ethical attorneys, or ministers who actually practice what they preach. Besides, every profession has its exceptions. Some people work very hard to become one.

 

A Name That Once Evoked Something Better

 

When I first heard the name Ramaswamy, I was pleasantly reminded of my all-time favorite customer at my Asian grocery store in Toledo: Dr. Ayyaswamy Thambuswamy, born in Chennai, India, in 1932.

 

Dr. Thambuswamy was compassionate, kind, and loved by everyone he encountered. He represented the sort of decency that makes a person memorable long after the details of an ordinary day have faded.

 

The last thing I could imagine him doing would be attacking the credibility of a woman who, according to the account at the heart of this controversy, was sexually abused by her stepfather when she was just 12 years old.

 

Unfortunately, sharing a name with someone who inspires fond memories is no guarantee that the next person bearing a similar name will inspire anything remotely resembling them.

 

A name can remind you of kindness. A political advertisement can remind you why skepticism was invented.

 

Four Million Dollars for What, Exactly?

 

Ramaswamy has faced criticism over an advertisement targeting Amy Acton that features her mother, whom Acton’s account portrays as having sided with the stepfather accused of raping her. According to the account described here, Acton was abandoned along with her brother after the stepfather was indicted, and the estrangement from her mother has lasted decades.

 

These are extraordinarily painful circumstances. They deserve something better than being turned into political ammunition.

 

Yet, as described, the advertisement puts the mother's role in the story at the center of a political attack on Acton. That raises a straightforward question: What, precisely, is the point of spending millions of dollars to put a family’s most painful history on display?

 

Four million dollars is an astonishing amount of money to spend on an advertisement that invites voters to judge a survivor through the conduct of a parent who failed to protect her.

 

Apparently, the campaign's advertising consultants decided that what this story really needed was a multimillion-dollar political makeover. Because nothing says compassionate public service quite like dragging a family tragedy into a campaign and hoping the audience forgets to ask who is actually being targeted.

 

One might reasonably expect a candidate seeking public office to demonstrate some appreciation for the difference between scrutinizing a person's public record and exploiting a deeply personal trauma.

 

That distinction may not make for a particularly catchy attack ad. It does, however, matter.

 

And if Ramaswamy believes the advertisement is fair, he should be prepared to explain exactly why. A candidate who spends millions trying to shape public opinion ought to be able to defend the substance of his message without hiding behind the fact that an advertisement has already aired.

 

If he believes the ad was justified, let him make the case. If it crossed a line, an acknowledgment would be a refreshing change of pace in a political culture where admitting a mistake is apparently considered more dangerous than making one.

 

An apology, after all, costs considerably less than four million dollars.

 

The November Verdict

 

I hope Ohio voters take a hard look at this controversy before casting their ballots on November 3. They can examine the advertisement, consider the circumstances described by Acton, assess Ramaswamy’s explanation, and decide for themselves whether this is the kind of political conduct they want to reward.

 

They should also ask whether the financial backers of such campaigns are getting a return on their investment in anything other than outrage.

 

There is, of course, a simple democratic remedy for politicians whose tactics voters find objectionable: the ballot box. No elaborate investigation into anyone's character is required. Voters can evaluate the conduct, weigh the evidence, and deliver their verdict.

 

And if Ramaswamy's approach strikes them as an example of politics at its most cynical, they can make that judgment unmistakably clear.

 

After all, elections are the one occasion when voters get to send a politician a message without paying a four-million-dollar advertising agency to write it for them.

 

No multimillion-dollar production budget. No dramatic soundtrack. No carefully edited footage. Just a ballot and a decision.

 

For a candidate who has spent so much money trying to influence the public conversation, that might be the most sobering advertisement of all.

 

 

Who's Online

We have 619 guests online

Donation Request

Your donations are needed to help defray the recurring costs for internet services, cable access, research via LexisNexis, media subscriptions, and the employment of a researcher and editor.

Donate Here

Каталог сортов растений

website counter