| ► Why Are Judges Judged by Judges? |
|
|
|
► Why Are Judges Judged by Judges?
The Judicial Industry would like the public to believe its members are the ethical equivalent of Olympic saints. According to the official narrative, judges are impartial, honorable, and steadfast guardians of justice whose commitment to ethical conduct borders on the supernatural.
Then a misconduct complaint gets filed.
And suddenly the magic begins.
No matter how serious the allegations, no matter how compelling the evidence, and no matter how outrageous the conduct may appear to ordinary citizens, the accused judge often emerges from the process looking suspiciously untarnished. Like a tuxedo at a mud-wrestling competition, not a spot to be found.
To ask why this happens is to answer the question.
If judicial disciplinary systems were genuinely designed to expose and remove judges guilty of misconduct, why are complaints so often hidden from public view? Why is secrecy treated as a virtue?
Just as importantly, why is the responsibility for judging judicial misconduct so frequently entrusted to other judges?
Perhaps because the Judicial Industry would prefer that the public never discover that some judges may be:
Domestic abusers. Chronic alcohol abusers. So monumentally lazy that litigants wait months, and occasionally years, for rulings. Bullies who intimidate attorneys, litigants, witnesses, and anyone else unlucky enough to cross their path. Profanity enthusiasts who apparently mistake a courtroom for a truck stop parking lot. Incompetent jurists repeatedly reversed by appellate courts while taxpayers foot the bill for the resulting chaos. Openly biased officials who somehow find that friends, political allies, and campaign supporters are remarkably deserving of favorable treatment.
Of course, we are assured that the disciplinary process works brilliantly.
And if you can't trust people to objectively judge their colleagues, friends, and professional associates, who can you trust?
To illustrate the point, consider the following hypothetical.
Suppose the Texas Legislature enacted a law providing that only convicted pedophiles could serve on juries deciding cases involving child molestation.
Predictably, the public would be horrified.
Victims would be horrified.
Judges would be horrified.
Newspapers would be horrified.
Civil rights groups would be horrified.
In fact, everyone with a pulse would be horrified.
Now suppose one of those juries acquitted a defendant despite overwhelming evidence.
Would anyone be surprised?
"Now hold on, Dave," some readers may object. "That's a ridiculous comparison."
Perhaps.
But it highlights a legitimate concern. When members of any profession are given primary responsibility for investigating and disciplining fellow members of the same profession, the incentives are obvious. Institutional loyalty has an unfortunate tendency to compete with accountability.
And accountability does not always win.
My imaginary critic, Delmas, is undoubtedly squirming by now.
"Dave, surely judges are capable of being objective."
Of course they are.
The question is not whether they are capable of objectivity.
The question is why the public should be asked to blindly assume it exists when the process itself is largely shielded from public scrutiny.
Transparency does not weaken confidence in government institutions.
It creates confidence.
Secrecy, on the other hand, tends to create suspicion, especially when those conducting the investigation belong to the same club as the person being investigated.
Funny how that works.
The legal profession routinely reminds the public that justice must not only be done, but must also be seen to be done.
Apparently, that principle is extremely important right up until the moment a judge becomes the subject of an ethics complaint.
Then, somehow, seeing becomes optional.
In closing, if you find this system as troubling as I do, contact your state legislators and urge them to pursue meaningful judicial accountability reforms.
Because doing nothing guarantees more of the same.
And the Judicial Industry appears perfectly content with a system in which judges investigate judges, judges clear judges, and judges assure everyone that judges are doing an outstanding job policing judges.
What could possibly go wrong? |

